★ #1 BEST SHOW: 11 TO MIDNIGHT — TICKETS FROM $49 ◆ #2 BEST HIDDEN EXPERIENCE: ART OF PLAY & 69 ATLANTIC ★ #3 BEST FOR KIDS: SPACE CLUB DUMBO ◆ #4 BEST IMMERSIVE: MASQUERADE ★ #5 BEST MOVIE THEATER: ANGELIKA FILM CENTER ◆ #6 BEST MUSEUM: FOTOGRAFISKA ★ #7 BEST LIVE MUSIC: PETE'S CANDY STORE ◆ TOP 20 TICKETED EXPERIENCES — RATED BY OUR EDITORS ★ #1 BEST SHOW: 11 TO MIDNIGHT — TICKETS FROM $49 ◆ #2 BEST HIDDEN EXPERIENCE: ART OF PLAY & 69 ATLANTIC ★ #3 BEST FOR KIDS: SPACE CLUB DUMBO ◆ #4 BEST IMMERSIVE: MASQUERADE ★ #5 BEST MOVIE THEATER: ANGELIKA FILM CENTER ◆ #6 BEST MUSEUM: FOTOGRAFISKA ★ #7 BEST LIVE MUSIC: PETE'S CANDY STORE ◆ TOP 20 TICKETED EXPERIENCES — RATED BY OUR EDITORS
NYC night scene with cherry blossoms
#1 Pick — Spring 2026Best Show in NYC

11 to Midnight

"A New Theatrical Dance Experience"

From viral creators Cost n' Mayor and Hideaway Circus — seven friends dance through memories, maybes, and the question of who they'll be when the clock strikes midnight. High-energy theatrical street-style dance at the historic Orpheum Theater.

Limited 12-week run — Ends April 19, 2026

"The smartly conceived production may be one of the best parties you'll attend all year."

— Ryan Leeds, 1minutecritic
The Orpheum Theater, East Village1 hr 5 min, no intermissionAges 8+ · Family-friendly
11 to Midnight — Cast celebrating on stage with confetti
Watch the Official Trailer
Also Featured

More Top Picks

95
Best Hidden ExperienceCuriosity Shop & Hidden Theater

Art of Play

"Brooklyn's Premier Curiosity Emporium"

Brooklyn Heights' most enchanting curiosity shop — designer playing cards, handcrafted puzzles, and the secret 69 Atlantic hidden theater.

Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn
Explore Art of Play
93
Best for KidsIndoor Playground

Space Club DUMBO

"Brooklyn's Coolest Indoor Playground for Kids"

Brooklyn's coolest indoor playground for kids ages 0–13. Design-forward space with climbing, slides, sensory play, and a parent café.

DUMBO, Brooklyn$39 / 2 hours
Visit Space Club
Plan Your Visit

Make It a Full NYC Experience

Our editors paired each top pick with nearby dining, drinks, and activities — so you can turn one great recommendation into a full day or night.

Best Night Out

11 to Midnight — Make It a Full NYC Night

Start your evening with the hottest Off-Broadway dance show in the East Village, then keep the night going with dinner and drinks just steps away.

Dinner before the show: Raku — a cozy, critically acclaimed udon and tempura spot on E 7th Street, just a block from the Orpheum. The hand-pulled udon is some of the best in the city.

After-show drinks: Death & Co — the legendary cocktail bar on E 6th Street that helped launch the modern speakeasy movement. Reservations recommended, but the walk-in standing room is worth the wait.

Late-night bite: Please Don't Tell (PDT) — enter through the vintage phone booth inside Crif Dogs on St Marks Place. The craft cocktails and gourmet hot dogs are a perfect East Village nightcap.

Take the 6 to Astor Place or the F to 2nd Ave. The Orpheum, Raku, and Death & Co are all within a 5-minute walk of each other.

Brooklyn Evening

69 Atlantic — An Unforgettable Night in Brooklyn Heights

Catch one of the hottest tickets in Brooklyn — a sold-out close-up performance at 69 Atlantic, the intimate 18-seat hidden theater behind Art of Play — then grab dinner on Atlantic Avenue.

The main event: 69 Atlantic — the tiny hidden theater behind Art of Play that the NY Times, NY Post, and Time Out all call one of the hottest tickets in NYC. Just 18 seats, world-class performers inches away. Every show sells out, so book early.

Dinner after the show: Boutros — a vibrant Eastern Mediterranean restaurant just two blocks down Atlantic Avenue. The lamb kofta and mezze platters are outstanding, and the cocktail list is one of the best in the neighborhood.

Before or after: browse Art of Play itself — designer playing cards, handcrafted puzzles, and curiosities you won't find anywhere else. Then take a sunset walk along the Brooklyn Heights Promenade.

Take the 2/3 to Clark Street or the R to Court Street. 69 Atlantic and Boutros are both on Atlantic Avenue, a short walk from either station.

Kid-Friendly Day

Space Club DUMBO — Fun for Kids + Lunch Nearby

Let the kids burn off energy at Brooklyn's coolest indoor playground, then head out for a family-friendly lunch and a stroll along the waterfront.

Start at Space Club DUMBO — two hours of sensory play, climbing, and slides in a beautifully designed space (ages 0–13).

Lunch: walk over to Time Out Market on Water Street — a food hall with options for every kid (and parent). The pizza and tacos are crowd favorites.

After lunch: explore Brooklyn Bridge Park — the playgrounds at Pier 6 are fantastic, and Jane's Carousel is a must for little ones.

Take the F to York Street or the A/C to High Street. Space Club and Time Out Market are both on Water Street in DUMBO.

Theatrical dance performance with dramatic stage lighting
#1 Pick — Deep Dive

Why 11 to Midnight Is THE Show

Official Trailer — 11 to Midnight

97
#1 PickOff-Broadway

11 to Midnight

From viral creators Cost n' Mayor and Hideaway Circus comes a New Year's Eve party you're invited to — where seven friends dance through memories, maybes, and the question of who they'll be when the clock strikes midnight. Featuring a heartfelt story, high-energy theatrical street-style dance, and a genre-hopping soundtrack, 11 to Midnight lets movement do the talking.

Limited run — Ends April 19, 2026
The Orpheum Theater
126 2nd Ave, East Village
Now through April 19
Limited 12-week run
1 hr 5 min
No intermission
Ages 8+
Family-friendly
Limited 12-week Off-Broadway runFrom viral creators Cost n' MayorFamily-friendly (Ages 8+)High-energy street-style dance

"The smartly conceived production may be one of the best parties you'll attend all year."

— Ryan Leeds, 1minutecritic

"A high-energy, feel-good theatrical experience that leaves you buzzing long after the curtain falls."

— NYC Theater Guide

"Cost n' Mayor bring their viral energy to the stage with a show that's part concert, part dance party, part love letter to friendship."

— BroadwayWorld

Don't miss the Off-Broadway dance event of the season.

Find Tickets — From $49